P-03 · Part IV · NOMOS-SPEC-015 0.2.0
Issuance
Updated Nov 12, 2026 · Seal the Decision, Not the Document
A sealed authority binds only when the institution, by its own constitution as it stood when the seal was made, authorized exactly that sealing, with every consent from a holder certified for its role, whatever any key-holder signs.
Found by the proof · Nov 12, 2026
Two gaps in the first draft, both closed in 0.2.0
- The proof chose its own time. Currency was judged at the time the issuance proof states, so a November seal whose proof claimed May was issued under April's superseded constitution. Now currency is judged when the seal was made, as the relying party knows it, and the proof's time must lie within a bound of that.
- Consents were counted by the role they claimed. The faithless officer could write his own quorum, for a policy or for a friendlier constitution. Now a consent counts only from a holder certified for its role.
Caught by this proof · 3 gaps, all closed
- An issuance proof could choose its own date
- Consents were counted by the role they claimed
- Two constitutions starting together made the answer order-dependent
What each one was, and how it was closed →
Proved · Lean 4, core library, standard axioms
| Claim | Theorem |
|---|---|
| Officer indifference: ISSUED means the pinned genesis, every amendment issued under its predecessor, exactly this seal, the constitution in force when it was made, and n distinct certified holders over exactly this issuance | officer_indifference |
| The sealing key alone mints nothing | no_proof_no_authority |
| One stolen director key is one vote | one_key_one_vote |
| Dropping C9, C10, C11 or C12 lets the faithless officer, the stale constitution, the counterfeit institution or the midnight amendment through | C9_necessary … C12_necessary |
| In 0.1.0 a backdated proof and invented consents were issued; 0.2.0 refuses both | backdating_issues, invented_consents_issue, forged_amendment |
Attacks
The reference verifier refuses every one, and each succeeds when exactly its own condition is removed, and under no other.
| Attack | Stopped by |
|---|---|
| The faithless officer | C9 |
| The invented consents | C9 · certified consents |
| The stale constitution | C10 |
| The backdated issuance | C10 · seal time |
| The self-certified genesis | C11 |
| The midnight amendment | C12 |
Not yet proved
- What a constitution requires for an act: SPEC-008's evaluator, assumed here; its omission safety is P-01.
- Signatures, and how a holder comes to be certified for a role (SPEC-007): hypotheses, not modelled.
- The real issuance path: a proof emitted by the Registry's approval flow as a committed SPEC-008 Act is not built yet.
- Independence: one implementation so far. SPEC-015 stays Draft until a second passes every vector.
Run it yourself
git clone https://github.com/nomos-spec/spec cd spec/papers/issuance/lean && lean Issuance.lean # Lean 4.35 # the 17 vectors: issuance-vectors/vectors.json