R-24 · 5 min · Design Note
Who Runs the Roots
Published Nov 12, 2026
Abstract
Every NOMOS verdict is checked against roots and registrars the receiving system chose. This note sets out who operates them: the institutions that rely on them govern the roots and the registrar rules, NOMOS writes the standard and operates under contract, and governance of the platform root passes to that body once five unaffiliated institutions operate a root, a registrar or an independent implementation.
R-09 · Design Note
Root Legitimacy for Machine-Executable Institutional Authority →
R-09: the candidate governance models for a root, red-teamed against web PKI, DNSSEC, RPKI and accreditation.
R-20 · Paper
Resolve the Law, Not the Catalogue →
R-20: what a registrar signs, and why an absent law counts only under a completeness statement.
Concept
What a root decides
Every verdict in NOMOS is checked against keys the receiving system chose. A root key certifies the keys below it: the issuer that seals an authority, the witnesses whose statements supply facts, the approvers whose consent an escalation needs (NOMOS-SPEC-007). Since rev. 1.11 only the root grants witness or approver authority; every certificate below it can only narrow. A registrar signs which authorities govern where, and for which places its list is complete (NOMOS-SPEC-014).
No verdict passes through NOMOS. An Act arrives by any route and the system that would commit it verifies it itself, against the roots and registrars it pins. That is the design. It also locates control precisely: whoever holds a root can certify or revoke, and whoever runs a registrar can add a law to a place or withdraw one. The question this note answers is who holds them.
The model
- The roots and the registrar rules are governed by the institutions that rely on them: authorities whose law is listed, regulators, industry bodies, and the operators of independent implementations. Membership is earned by operating something: a root, a registrar, or an implementation that passes the published conformance vectors.
- NOMOS writes the specifications, builds the reference software and operates services under contract to that body. SafeHaven LLC is the operator.
- Roots are plural. A jurisdiction runs its own root; a sector runs its own registrar; registrars defer to one another for a scope with signed recognition edges. Each receiving system pins the roots and registrars it accepts, and several coexist.
- Every rule change is an entry in a public, append-only log, signed and verifiable offline. Governance is exercised in the log, where anyone can audit it, not in a meeting record.
What runs today
NOMOS operates the platform root and the platform registrar. The register lists the EU AI Act and the data protection laws of the UAE, the DIFC and Qatar, each claim written against the law's own scope article, and states completeness for those places. Every entry is checked before it is signed, changes need a second approver once a registrar has two, completeness statements lapse after 90 days unless renewed, and the whole log verifies offline with the published key or a key you hold. Institutions seal with keys in their own KMS or HSM.
The handover
Governance of the platform root and registrar rules passes from NOMOS to the participants' body once five institutions unaffiliated with NOMOS operate a root, a registrar or an independent implementation. The body's first charter is drafted with those first operators. Until then NOMOS operates under the rules in this note, and each change to them is a signed entry in the log.
The commitment is published in advance because the alternative is a single operator asking to be trusted. Infrastructure that strangers rely on has to be governed by the parties who rely on it; the operator earns its place by running it well.
Operating a registrar
- A signing key, held in your own KMS or HSM.
- Claims written against each law's own scope article: where it applies, with the provision it rests on.
- A completeness statement for each place you cover, renewed before it lapses.
- A public log in the NOMOS-SPEC-014 format. Any receiving system reads it with registrarSource(), the same reader that checks the platform registrar.
Operate a registrar or a root
Authorities, regulators, industry bodies and implementers: tell us what you would operate and for which laws or places. It goes straight to Allan.
Cite this
This is a field in formation; this page will be revised. Cite the version date below, not the day you happen to be reading this.
Suggested citation
SafeHaven (2026). Who Runs the Roots. Computable Authority Research Library, version of 2026-11-12. https://www.computableauthority.com/research/who-runs-the-roots
BibTeX
@misc{computableauthority-who-runs-the-roots,
author = {SafeHaven},
title = {Who Runs the Roots},
howpublished = {Computable Authority Research Library},
year = {2026},
note = {Version of 2026-11-12},
url = {https://www.computableauthority.com/research/who-runs-the-roots},
}Next entry
What is Computable Authority? →